COMMONS SENSE:
TRAGEDY OF THE COMMONS

Image  for Commons

Background Information

An important concept embedded in the current mainstream of environmental education and science education, both formal and informal, is "sustainability."

Sustainability has broad and widespread applications within economics, resource management, and artificial systems. The context being considered here is ecological sustainability which can be defined as: "To meet the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs." (World Commission on Environment and Development, 1987).

Photo: Cod fishermenAs ecosystem natural resource conservation and preservation efforts occur, the ability to sustain that ecosystem or natural resource is of primary consideration. This is not an easy process. For decades fisheries managers have struggled to develop optimal sustainable yields. The crash of the North Atlantic Cod industry is evidence that using the best science of biological and economic models failed to sustain that fishery.
The need for resource management for sustainability evolved from the over-utilization of limited resources. These resources were often shared resources such as pastures, ranges, fisheries, forests, water, and air. In 1968, Garrett Hardin published an essay in Science titled "The Tragedy of the Commons." In this context a "commons" is any resource used as though it belongs to all. A commons is destroyed by over-utilization, lack of personal ownership, and lack of Photo: Sheep grazing.control. Hardin uses a public pasture to illustrate such an exploitation. Herdsmen can quickly exceed the carrying capacity of that pasture (system) and thus degrade or completely destroy the pasture (resource). Hardin's pasture is also considered to be a metaphor for shared aspects of our society, such as our communities, roads, air, and water.
An Internet search for Tragedy of the Commons yielded several hundred matches. This is an indication that the concept of the Tragedy of the Commons and how to best utilize, manage, and conserve resources for sustainability is widely discussed. Social, economic, and political issues are often embedded in these discussions.
Photo: Harbor

In an article in the journal Science titled "Principles for Sustainable Governance of the Oceans," five major Tragedy-of-the-Commons-related marine problems are identified:

  1. overfishing;
  2. ocean disposal and spills;
  3. destruction of coastal ecosystems;
  4. land-based contamination; and
  5. climate change.
Each problem area is suitable for student exploration and learning. These problems facing our oceans provide excellent opportunities for students to apply "commons thinking" to their ecological decision-making and stewardship practices. Why? Because the vast oceans are being impacted by the pressure exerted by humanity on global resources. Therefore, the largest ecosystems on earth are calling out for sustainable management. The ten keys to successful resource management include:
Photo: Boston commons.

Equal access
Economics
Social fairness
Integration
Recognition of potential impacts
Social and individual decision making
Restoration
Preservation
Management
Multiple use

Enviro-TackleboxTM Logo
Click to return to the Enviro-TackleboxTM.

Link to the LPB Learning Port.
Click to return to the LPB Learning Port.

Link to LPB Interactive
Click to return to LPB Interactive.


Go to Real Media to download your FREE player!